- Sideways at #9?! Shouldn't be on the list. I chuckled a few times, sure, I'm not saying it's a bad movie ... it's just not anywhere near that good.
- Sex, Lies, and Videotape? I must be the only person that thinks this is, maybe, Soderbergh's 5th best movie.
- I'm less bothered by The Usual Suspects at #8. It would be on my list of 50, just not near the top.
- The Terminator's inclusion, I wouldn't have thought it was 'indie'? But I guess when James Cameron does it, he just goes big.
- 29th seems like a reach for Keitel's The Bad Lieutenant. I was bored and didn't pay much attention to it, so I don't remember it too well. But, I can't believe it's a good sign that what I remember about it is being bored and thinking "overrated."
- The Blair Witch Project ahead of Grosse Point Blanke? I think not. At least flip them, then drop BWP (off the list) and push GPB up a few more places.
- There's no way El Mariachi should've been the last one in.
- Swingers belongs in the top 20, not at the back end.
- City of God at #17 is better than at least 5 of the movies rated ahead of it.
Pages
▼
Thursday, November 10, 2005
Another List to Nitpick
Empire's 50 Greatest Independent Films